Fat vs Muscle: Not all 5lbs Are Made Equal

When it comes to fitness and body composition, the number on the scale is just the tip of the iceberg. The composition of your body matters as much, if not more, than your total weight. In this blog post, we’re going to dive deep into the differences between 5 pounds of muscle and 5 pounds of fat, shedding light on why it’s essential to focus on more than just the numbers.

muscle is more dense

One of the first and most striking differences between muscle and fat is their density. Muscle is denser than fat, meaning it takes up less space for the same weight. This is why someone with more muscle mass can appear leaner and more toned, even if they weigh the same as someone with more fat. In contrast, fat is bulkier and takes up more space under your skin.

To put it simply, imagine a pound of feathers and a pound of bricks. Both weigh the same, but the bricks occupy far less space than the feathers. Similarly, 5 pounds of muscle will look and feel much more compact than 5 pounds of fat.


Another significant difference is that muscle is metabolically active tissue, whereas fat is not. Muscle requires more energy to maintain, so it contributes to your basal metabolic rate (BMR) – the number of calories your body burns at rest. In contrast, fat is largely metabolically inactive and does not contribute as much to how many calories your body burns at rest.

This means that having more muscle mass can boost your metabolism, making it easier to maintain or lose weight, support hormone regulation and digestion. It’s like having a built-in calorie-burning engine in your body. On the other hand, excess fat can slow down your metabolism, making weight management more challenging.

Muscle Supports Functional Strength

Muscle isn’t just about aesthetics; it plays a crucial role in your overall physical function. Having more muscle mass can improve your strength, balance, and mobility, making everyday tasks easier and reducing the risk of injury. Whether you’re carrying groceries, playing sports, or simply getting up from a chair, strong muscles are your allies.

Excess Fat Storage Can Contribute to Other Health Conditions

Fat serves as an energy reserve, but excessive fat storage can have health implications. Excess body fat, especially when concentrated around the abdomen, is associated with an increased risk of various health conditions, including heart disease, diabetes, and certain cancers. On the other hand, a higher percentage of muscle can be associated with improved insulin sensitivity and better overall health.

Muscle Wins The Battle

In the battle of 5 pounds of muscle versus 5 pounds of fat, it’s clear that muscle comes out on top in terms of density, metabolic activity, and overall health benefits. While the number on the scale may not change much, focusing on building and preserving muscle can lead to a leaner, healthier, and more functional body.

So, remember that your fitness journey should go beyond just losing weight. Aim to build and maintain muscle, not only for a toned appearance but also for the numerous health advantages it brings. Whether you’re a fitness enthusiast or someone just starting their journey, understanding these differences can help you make more informed choices about your health and well-being.

If you’re looking for help to get started and want to build the health you know you deserve, our team will support you. It’s important to make sure as you start you include the right foods to eat, the proper exercises to do, and to make sure the program is giving all the benefits without compromising any other aspects of your health, such as injured joints or poor sleep or over-exercising stress. Understanding how to program or train for muscle building takes time to add it into your daily routine. Work with us, and we’ll get you there!

Nana-adjoa Bourne Naturopathic Doctor

Dr. Nana-Adjoa Bourne, ND

Dr. Bourne is a Naturopathic Doctor and certified Sports Nutritionist at Axis Therapy & Performance located in Toronto. She works from the inside-out, supporting performance optimization and injury recovery alongside physical rehabilitation. She also incorporates IV Therapy into her treatment protocols

Axis Therapy & Performance – Physiotherapy, Chiropractor, RMT Scarborough
1585 Markham Rd, Unit 308
Scarborough, ON M1B 2W1

Axis Therapy & Performance – Physiotherapy, Chiropractor, RMT, Naturopath Riverdale
377 Broadview Ave, Unit 101
Toronto, ON M4K 2M7

%d bloggers like this: